![]() Injustice at whatever level brings chaos, discord, unhappiness. What of man and his virtue in this instance? Man's virtue herein is his justice it enables him to live well in harmony with others and to be happy. The eye sees, the ear hears, the pruning knife cuts well. Socrates' next argument advances analogies of the pruning hook, the eye, the ear, and the soul, all of which possess their several essences, what we may call their essential functions, or virtues. Unjust men, at whatever level of their practicing injustice, degenerate from an assumed strength to weakness. That is, they too have to practice a kind of justice otherwise, a gang of thieves would break up and their little "state" would degenerate into disunity, chaos, unhappiness. Next, Socrates reminds Thrasymachus that even thieves have to trust one another and to show it by a fair division of their ill-gotten gain. We notice, Socrates says, that it is the ignorant man who always attempts home-remedies always the man ignorant of music who attempts to outdo the musician and thereby shows his ignorance of the art. In his argument at this point, Socrates again employs analogies, in this case the physician and the flute-player. Socrates says that Thrasymachus is wrong on three counts: that the unjust man is more knowledgeable than the just, that injustice is a source of strength and that injustice brings happiness. At this point, Thrasymachus would like to leave the debate. The more power, the better: The tyrant's life is the good life. ![]() And if one steals, Thrasymachus says, one ought to steal big. Injustice ( adikia) is the best course of action the unjust man can take advantage of his fellows in every instance he can cheat on his taxes, rob the public coffers and defraud the public, juggle books in a position of trust, and so on. Strong men and intelligent men have the courage to do wrong they can out-think simpler citizens and overpower weaker ones, weaker in whatever sense. He argues that most people are "good" in appearance only they do "right" things or try to pursue dike (the way things ought to be) only because they are ignorant, or stupid, or afraid of the punishment of the law. Thrasymachus continues to bluster and to engage in persiflage (whistle-talk).
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |